Thursday, November 12, 2015

Did you know that some snakes are threatened and endangered in Ontario?



The first impression that comes across your mind when you see a snake lying on the highway is probably one of the following:
  1. “Oh my goodness!”
  2. “Ew.”
  3. “Just run it over, no big deal!”
  4. All of the above


However, have you ever imagined a world without snakes, if we kill them all?
In our ecosystems, snakes are one of the most important components of the mid-order predators. Without snakes, the number of prey species, including rodents, harmful bugs, and insects, would increase to unnatural extents. This would in turn lead to severe reduction in crop production because of the disappearing of the natural pest control, snakes! Also, the higher order predators (some birds, and other bigger snakes) who prey on snakes would be having difficulties hunting because of the lower food abundance.


What exactly have we done to the global snakes population?
The global snake and reptile populations have been shown to demonstrate similar declining patterns (Reading et al. 2010; Whitfield Gibbons et al. 2000). These studies suggested snake populations need our attention because for some of them, human activities have been the cause of declines. Currently in Ontario, there are 9 snakes species listed as threatened or endangered in the Species at Risk list (Environmental Canada 2015). With timber rattlesnakes being extirpated in Ontario, it is critical and urgent that we take actions to protect snakes in Ontario. You are probably thinking “I have never killed/run over a single snake”.


But here is a list of anthropogenic activities that could potentially affect the snakes populations:




References:


C. J. Reading, L. M. Luiselli, G. C. Akani, X. Bonnet, G. Amori, J. M. Ballouard, E. Filippi, G. Naulleau, D. Pearson and L. Rugiero. (2010). Are snake populations in widespread decline? Biology Letters doi:10.1098.

Environmental Canada. (2015). Species at risk list in Ontario.  
https://www.ontario.ca/environment-and-energy/species-risk-ontario-list

Whitfield Gibbons, J., D. E. Scott., T. J. Ryan., K. A. Buhlmann., T. D. Tuberville., B. S. Metts., J. L. Greene., T. Mills., Y. Leiden., S. Poppy., and C. T. Winne. (2000). The Global Decline of Reptiles, Déjà Vu Amphibians. Bioscience 50(8): 653-666.

Wednesday, November 11, 2015

The importance of “unattractive” snakes

Conservation efforts are generally targeted towards “attractive” animals because the general public is more concerned with “cute” animals going extinct. These flagship species are generally large mammals used as an icon of conservation organizations, and are considered to be charismatic to the general public. Research studies have revealed that the majority of conservation fundraising and research focusses on flagship species, mainly large mammal species; whereas, little to no attention was given to the non-flagship reptiles and amphibians (Joseph et al. 2011; Smith et al. 2012). This means that the vast majority of the public are more willing to donate money to save the endangered pandas, but no one really cares about snakes. 
Unfortunately, flagship species only represent a small portion of all the currently listed endangered species (Joseph et al. 2011; Smith et al. 2012). Oftentimes, conservation efforts made on non-flagship species rely on flagship species fundings; however, Benett et al. (2015) found that this allocated funding was small and inefficient for most non-flagship species.



In Ontario snakes are considered unappealing due to misconceptions that they are dangerous, even venomous. At the same time a number of Ontario snake species are at risk, with many falling onto threatened or endangered species lists (Environmental Canada 2015). Unfortunately, Ontario residents are generally uninformed and unwilling to help in the conservation of these species due to their aversion to snakes. This can sometimes compound the threats facing snakes in Ontario, for example in the instance of (intentional) road kill. In a Harris Poll conducted by Taylor (1999), ophidiophobia, the abnormal fear of snakes, was reported to be the most common fear shown in adults. Perhaps this fear of snakes has led to the status and crisis of snakes species.
As mentioned in Did you know that some snakes are threatened and endangered in Ontario?, snakes are actually of huge importance in our ecosystems. Snakes and many other non-flagship species also need public attention in conservation. Unfortunately, most of the time we are unaware of the fact that our daily actions could potentially threaten these endangered species.

Importance of conserving and studying snakes

Apart from the important roles snakes play in our ecosystem, scientists study snakes for various reasons in hope to accentuate the many positive aspects of snake biology. Snakes are a common model organism for studying the ecological effects of human infrastructure, such as road mortality (e.g. Shepard et al. 2008; Garrah et al. 2015), and habitat fragmentation (e.g. Robson and Blouin-Demers, 2013). These results contributed to our understanding of snakes habitat preference and their energetic adaptation to human-induced changes.

Snakes are also studied as an indicator species of the health of terrestrial ecosystem (Lillywhite 2010). Snakes are commonly used indicators of environmental contamination and pollution by pesticides, herbicides, insecticides residues (e.g. Stafford et al. 1976; Burger et al. 2004; Burger et al. 2007). Bioindicators exhibit changes in response to different stressors in the environment and the effects are relatively easy to measure for scientists. Long-lived snakes serve as a great bioindicator because they are top predators and show varied levels of accumulation of metal contaminants in blood, muscle, liver and skin (Burger et al. 2004; Burger et al. 2007).

Ectothermic snakes are also widely utilized to assess the effect of climate change on reptiles and amphibians. Even though certain degrees of plasticity were shown in young snakes adjusting their thermoregulatory behaviour, decreased fitness including decreased growth rate in cold-raised young, less locomotion, and less anti-predator responses were observed due to the lack of thermal plasticity in elder snakes (Aubret and Shine 2009). This study suggested that climate change would significantly affect the mean selected body temperatures because of a mismatch between thermoregulatory tactics and the ambient temperature (Aubret and Shine 2009). More on this: Climate change and potential threats on snakes.

References:
  
Aubret, F., and R. Shine. (2009). Thermal plasticity in young snakes: how will climate change affect the thermoregulatory tactics of ectotherms? The Journal of Experimental Biology 213: 242-248.

Burger, J., K. R. Campbell., T. S. Campbell., T. Shukla., C. Jeitner., and M. Gochfeld. (2004). Use of skin and blood as nonlethal indicators of heavy metal contamination in northern water snakes (Nerodia sipedon). Arch. Environ. Contam. Toxicol. 49: 232-238.

Burger, J., K. R. Campbell., S. Murray., T. S. Campbell., K. F. Gaines., C. Jeitner., T. Shukla., S. Burke., M. Gochfeld. (2007). Metal levels in blood, muscle and liver of water snakes (Nerodia spp.) from New Jersey, Tennessee and South Carolina. Science of the Total Environment 373: 556-563.

Environmental Canada. (2015). Species at risk list in Ontario.

Joseph, L. N., Maloney, R. F., Watson, J. E.M. and Possingham, H. P. (2011). Securing nonflagship species from extinction. Conservation Letters, 4: 324–325.

Lillywhite, H. B. (2010). Focus on snake conservation. Snakes: Ecology and Conservation. Bioscience 40(4): 315-317.

Smith, R.J., Verissimo, D., Isaac, N.J.B., & Jones, K.E. (2012). Identifying Cinderella species: Uncovering mammals with conservation flagship appeal. Conservation Letters 5: 205-212.

Taylor, H. (1999). What we are afraid of. The Harris Poll #49, August 18.

Robson, L. E., and G. Blouin-Demers. (2013). Eastern Hognose Snakes (Herodon platirhinos) avoid crossing paved roads, but not unpaved roads. Copeia 3: 507-511.

Correcting Misconceptions – Ontario Snakes are NOT Dangerous

            Despite popular belief, the snake species that inhabit Ontario are not dangerous. People often imagine snakes as aggressive, venomous animals that will go out of their way to harm humans. However, this perception of snakes is wildly incorrect. In reality, Ontario snakes tend to be docile and will avoid attacking a perceived threat (like humans) at all costs, if they attack at all. Even in the event of aggressive snake behaviour keep in mind that all Ontario snake species are non-venomous, with the exception of the eastern massasauga (Government of Ontario, “Massasauga Rattlesnake” 2015). Even in the case of the eastern massasauga though you do not need to be afraid.

Eastern Massasauga
The eastern massasauga, also known as the massasauga rattlesnake, is Ontario’s only venomous snake and the last remaining rattlesnake species in the province (Crowley, “Eastern Massasauga” 2015). Despite this, the eastern massasauga is not a threat to humans.

First of all, the eastern massasauga is very rare in Ontario and the chances of encountering this species are very low (Government of Ontario, “Massasauga Rattlesnake” 2015). Like most Ontario snake species the eastern massasauga is shy and non-aggressive in nature (Rowell, 2012). In the face of a threat, this species most often attempts to hide or retreat, not attack (Government of Ontario, “Massasauga Rattlesnake” 2015). In fact, research shows that even when approached eastern massasauga snakes tend to remain motionless, meaning you could closely pass by an individual and be none the wiser (Crowley, “Eastern Massasauga” 2015). If escape is not an option or a threat persists the nest step of defense for the eastern massasauga is to rattle its tail as a warning, but it will still resist attacking a predator (Government of Ontario, “Massasauga Rattlesnake” 2015).

Only as a very last resort will a massasauga snake attempt to strike and bite, and this species can only strike over a relatively small distance of about 30 cm (Crowley, “Eastern Massasauga” 2015). In the very unlikely event that you are bitten by an eastern massasauga there is still little likelihood of severe consequences, as long as proper follow up is carried out. In Ontario there have only been two deaths caused by a massasauga bite, both of which occurred over 50 years ago because proper medical attention was not sought out (Government of Ontario, “Massasauga Rattlesnake” 2015). In response to a bite from this species stay calm and immediately seek out medical care (Government of Ontario, “Massasauga Rattlesnake” 2015).

Negative connotations of the eastern massasauga, derived from it being venomous, carry over to other snake species even though they are (also) not dangerous. Consider for example the eastern hog-nosed snake, gray ratsnake and queensnake.


Eastern Hog-Nosed Snake



The aggressive defensive behaviors of the eastern hog-nosed snake. Photo Credit: Joe Crowley (Crowley, “Eastern Hog-Nosed Snake” 2015).

Perhaps one of the most misunderstood snake species in terms of perceived danger is the eastern hog-nosed snake, as a result of its defense strategies. When faced with a threat, eastern hog-nosed snakes often first attempt to flee, although if escape is unsuccessful the species can put on an impressive, and frightening, cobra-like display (Rowell, 2012). To scare away predators these snakes will take on a cobra-like stance of a raised head and neck, hiss loudly, and make mock strikes (with a closed mouth)  (Government of Ontario, “Eastern Hog-Nosed Snake” 2015). If all else fails the final defense strategy of eastern hog-nosed snakes is to play dead (Government of Ontario, “Eastern Hog-Nosed Snake” 2015). Remember that, while their defense strategy is very intimidating, eastern hog-nosed snakes are harmless and non-venomous.

I stress that hog-nosed snakes are non venomous because, while their saliva does contain mild toxins, it is not dangerous to humans (Rowell, 2012). The mild toxins produced by this species are not consider venom in the traditional definition of the term, as they can do not quickly kill prey (Rowell, 2012). Hog-nosed snakes cannot bite and inject these toxins into humans unless they are held for a long period of time, and even then, the toxins are not harmful to humans (Crowley, “Eastern Hog-Nosed Snake” 2015). It is important to note that hog-nosed snakes are very reluctant to bite any predator, and despite their frightening defense displays have a quite tame nature.

Gray Ratsnake
Although the gray ratsnake is harmless many individuals are scared of this species because of its large size (up to 2m!) and defense behaviors (Government of Ontario, “Gray Ratsnake” 2015). Most often when approached by a predator the gray ratsnake will freeze to avoid detection, but in some cases it will mimic the defence behaviors of the eastern massasauga by quickly vibrating its tail against the ground to make a warning rattle sound (Rowell, 2012). Thus, if you observe rattlesnake-like behavior it is important to remember that Ontario’s only rattlesnake is quite rare and other snake species that are non-venomous (e.g. the gray ratsnake) have similar defense behaviors, so you are very likely not in danger.

Queensnake
The queensnake is a shy and incredibly harmless snake species. Queensnakes are non-venomous and when threatened will always attempt to flee (Rowell, 2012). Even when humans handle them, very rarely do queensnakes bite but instead tend to squirm and release a fowl odor in attempts of being released (Rowell, 2012).

Like any animal snakes exhibit defensive behaviour in the presence of a threat, such as a human which is much larger than itself. Always keep in mind that, while these defense behaviors can be intimidating, all snake species in Ontario are harmless to humans. Of course, knowing that Ontario snakes are not dangerous does not mean you won’t be scared if you see one in the wild, but know that as long as you do not engage with a snake that is displaying aggressive defense behaviour you are not threatened in any way.

References:


Government of Ontario. (2015). Massasauga Rattlesnake. http://www.ontario.ca/page/massasauga-rattlesnake.

Government of Ontario. (2015). Eastern Hog-Nosed Snake. http://www.ontario.ca/page/eastern-hog-nosed-snake.

Government of Ontario. (2015). Gray Ratsnake. http://www.ontario.ca/page/gray-ratsnake.

Rowell, J. (2012). The Snakes of Ontario: Natural History, Distribution and Status. Toronto, ON.

Tuesday, November 10, 2015

Ontario Snakes are at Risk


Ontario is home to 19 species of snakes, but many of these species are either of special concern, threatened or endangered (Rowell, 2012). The Committee on the Status of Endangered Wildlife in Canada (CSEWIC) has determined that 7 Ontario snake species are endangered, meaning they face immediate extirpation/extinction, and that 2 species are threatened, meaning that unless actions are taken the species is very likely to become endangered. Three of these at risk Ontario species are the eastern hog-nosed snake, gray ratsnake and queensnake.

Fig. 2. A gray ratsnake. Photo credit: Nick Caims (Argue, 2015).
Fig. 3. A queensnake. Photo credit: Scott Gillingwater (Crowley, “Queensnake” 2015). 

Eastern Hog-Nosed Snake (Heterodon platirhinos)

Fig. 1. An eastern hog-nosed snake, notice the characteristic upturned nose.  Photo Credit: Joe Crowley (Crowley, “Eastern Hog-Nosed Snake” 2015).

            As indicated by its common name, the eastern hog-nosed snake has a unique upturned snout, but other than this, appearance tends to vary between individuals (Crowley, “Eastern Hog-Nosed Snake” 2015).
Fig. 4. The current and historic Ontario range of the eastern hog-nosed snake (Crowley, “Eastern Hog-Nosed Snake” 2015).

            There are two regional populations of the eastern hog-nosed snake in Ontario, the southwestern population and the north-central population (Rowell, 2012). Figure 4 outlines the current and historic ranges of these two populations. Note that while the ranges appear quite large, in reality there are only a few locations that have viable population sizes, that is, populations of an adequate size to support survival (Rowell, 2012). As is demonstrated in the range map, the eastern hog-nosed snake is experiencing range reductions and population declines, mostly as a result of human activity (Rowell, 2012).
            The eastern hog-nosed snake faces a number of human-caused threats, including habitat disturbance, persecution, and road mortality.
·      Habitat Disturbance: The preferred habitats, specifically soil types, of the eastern hog-nosed snake tend to also be ideal sites for agriculture and waterfront development (Crowley, “Eastern Hog-Nosed Snake” 2015). Subsequently, human land use has lead to large-scale destruction of suitable area for this snake, and any remaining habitat is at threat of being developed and disturbed (Crowley, “Eastern Hog-Nosed Snake” 2015).
·      Persecution: While the eastern hog-nosed snake is harmless, under threat it sometimes carries out a frightening, cobra-like defensive display (Rowell, 2012). As a result, individuals are often killed by humans who mistake these snakes as being dangerous (Crowley, “Eastern Hog-Nosed Snake” 2015).
·      Road Mortality: Death due to vehicle collision is an increasing threat to eastern hog-nosed snakes, especially as road construction increases with the range of this species (Government of Ontario, “Eastern Hog-Nosed Snake” 2015).
These negative impacts that humans have on the eastern hog-nosed snake have lead to the species becoming threatened (Government of Ontario, “Eastern Hog-Nosed Snake” 2015). Unless action is taken to mitigate the threats human activates pose to these snakes, the species is likely to become endangered, even extinct.

Gray Ratsnake (Pantherophis spiloides)
            The gray ratsnake is the largest snake species in Ontario with individuals growing up to 2 m long (Government of Ontario, “Gray Ratsnake” 2015)! Considering its large size you may be surprised to learn that these snakes are excellent climbers and can often be found in trees, hunting for prey such as birds (Government of Ontario, “Gray Ratsnake” 2015).
Fig. 5. The current and historic Ontario range of the gray ratsnake (Argue, 2015).

            As shown in Figure 5, two populations of gray ratsnakes occur in Ontario, the Carolinian population and the Frontenac Axis population. While both are experiencing population declines they are at different levels of risk. The Carolinian population is endangered as a result of isolation caused by severe habitat disturbance, persecution and road mortality (Argue, 2015). This area is now densely inhabited by humans who have cut down much of the snake’s preferred forest habitat and often kill the harmless species out of unprecedented fear (Rowell, 2012). The same human activities have lead to the Frontenac Axis population, near Kingston ON, becoming threatened (Rowell, 2012). It is interesting to note that this population does benefit from the fragmenting of its habitat for agriculture as it increases the incidence of prey, but any benefit is offset by mortality caused by persecution and road kill as well as habitat disruption for cottage and urban development (Rowell, 2012).

Queensnake (Regina septemvittata)
            The queen snake is a semi-aquatic species and an excellent swimmer (Crowley, “Queensnake” 2015). These snakes never venture far from their very specialized habitats; clear water bodies with rocky bottoms like streams, rivers and lakes, where it preys predominantly on crayfish (Government of Ontario, “Queensnake” 2015). Due to their need for specific habitat and small home ranges, queensnakes are very poor dispersers  (Government of Ontario, “Queensnake” 2015). The inability to move to new habitats combined with multiple human-induced threats has lead to range and population declines of this species (as can be seen in figure 6), which have ultimately caused the queensnake to become endangered (Rowell, 2012).
Fig. 6. The current and historic Ontario range of the queensnake (Crowley, “Queensnake” 2015).


The extensive development that has occurred in southwest Ontario, particularly near waterways where queensnake are most common, pose many threats to the species (Rowell, 2012). Water control via dams, wetland draining, and shoreline development cause changes in water flow and turbidity, making habitats unsuitable for queensnakes (Rowell, 2012). In addition, queensnakes are more sensitive to water pollution than other reptiles as pollutants can easily penetrate their skin (Rowell, 2012). Aside from their direct negative impacts on queensnakes, all of these factors also indirectly harm this species as the resulting poor water quality leads to extreme population declines in crayfish, the queensnake’s main food source (Rowell, 2012). Recreational use of queensnake habitat also contributes to population declines. These snakes hide in shoreline rocks and so are often unintentionally trampled, in addition to being killed on purpose out of fear, even though queensnakes are harmless to humans (Crowley, “Queensnake” 2015).

            You may have noticed that these three Ontario snake species are threatened or endangered as a result of a common set of threats, all of which are founded in human activity. Indeed these threats (habitat disruption, persecution, and road mortality) in addition to climate change and the dangers of resulting small populations are putting snakes at risk all across Ontario.

References:



Government of Ontario. (2015). Eastern Hog-Nosed Snake. http://www.ontario.ca/page/eastern-hog-nosed-snake.

Government of Ontario. (2015). Queensnake. http://www.ontario.ca/page/queensnake.

Government of Ontario. (2015). Gray Ratsnake. http://www.ontario.ca/page/gray-ratsnake.


Rowell, J. (2012). The Snakes of Ontario: Natural History, Distribution and Status. Toronto, ON.